The Archer, Part 2

The illusion of the peace of arrival

This post continues The Archer, Part 1.

While I find so much in this short, sparse story valuable, nothing is more profound for me than the epilogue. There is nothing in the entire teaching on their walk home to prepare one for what follows.

After an entire narrative of teaching his student the pursuit of skill (attending to posture, aim, humility, awareness, thinking beyond the target, cultivating beneficial relationships, taking risks, remaining calm, giving full attention to what one is doing), Tetsuya arrives at his home and bids the boy goodbye, but the boy is not ready to leave. Beyond the teachings, the boy wants to know Tetsuya’s personal history, how he came to be the most accomplished and famous archer in the nation. Somewhat reluctantly, with an ambivalence not seen before this, he fixes tea and talks about his path.

The past is not fully redeemable

He tells the boy that in his youth, working for a nobleman who was often away, Tetsuya tended to the lord’s stable, but had so much free time he wasted his days pursuing “drink and women.” This leads to a day when he collapses far from his employer’s land, and he fears he will die. A stranger from far away happens by and takes him home to nurse him back to health. Tetsuya watches his rescuer and mentor practice the way of the bow each day, and begins to train. After much practice and dedication under the gaze of his guide, Tetsuya becomes proficient. His mentor now talks about his future.

Here is the surprising part. The man who saved his life and guides him into a grounded, authentic way of living tells him that because of his actions in the past, death is much closer to him than to others with a different past. For him, death will always be “two paces away.” He will always be walking on the edge of the abyss. Practicing a path of deliberate choices and following his passion will lengthen his life. His precision and wisdom in the way of the bow, his mindful attention to the bow, arrow, target and posture, is not based on overcoming the past, but on being aware of what he must be mindful of and manage for his whole life.

I don’t know how you react to this epilogue, but I expected to hear about a positive path to his mastery after years of dedication, and the past being redeemed because it led to his finding the way of the bow. His stress on attention, balance and calm does not mean liberation from the past. Instead, “Every second has been a struggle against my vices and against self-pity.” (130) Here is the strongest and least visible truth of growth. Tetsuya has achieved mastery, not complete redemption. You can achieve mastery without your personal struggle ending. In fact, an unending daily struggle is a necessary condition for mastery. Mastery is largely engaging the struggle without self-pity.

The false self

I could now talk about Christianity’s Paul in Romans 7 describing his ongoing inner struggle, or Rumi’s description of us “being drunk and on the edge of the roof,” but my point is better made, I think, by describing my own struggle.

As a child I was obese, and as so many heavy kids are, I was bullied. My family moved a great deal, and the same daily ridicule repeated wherever I was. I tried to find a way to be accepted. I had a reputation as being intelligent, and so I worked consciously and unconsciously to create a persona, not my true self but a self that would seem superior and intimidating to those judging me. It was a false self, but by projecting it, I had an uneasy way of surviving in a hostile environment. Uneasy because even when it worked, it was a mixed victory. At one high school I was working on the newspaper, and in an article introducing me to the school, the faculty advisor described me as “a mountain of a boy with a lot going for him upstairs.” I won’t get started on gym class. Enough to say it was brutal, and I decided it was fair game to find any way to be exempt from attending. I became a master at manipulating the system. I stayed in this place for a long time. When deciding what to say, how to act or how to dress, my thoughts were determined by how I would be received. This was such a long-embedded way of thinking that much of the time I was blind to what I was doing. It became my default for how I saw myself and the world.

Arriving is not fully arriving

Making a very long story very short, this did not change in a significant way until college. A major influence in my growth was the writing of the psychoanalyst Donald Winnicott and his description of the dynamics and growth of the true and false self. Another major influence came from study of some core Buddhist, Daoist and Jain concepts: in particular, the groundlessness of self, the impermanence of all phenomena and the freedom of non-attachment. Through reading and meditation I began to work on letting go of fear and defensiveness. The awareness of how essential it was not to bring my own issues into my therapy, and to be able to separate my feelings and reactions from those of my clients, was such a motivation to cultivate this change. Over the years my practice has deepened and my sense of self began changing. The world was less hostile, less foreign.

However, as with the epilogue, where I am now is not a steady state of peace and authenticity. It can be a struggle to recognize the familiar, almost default way of hiding behind that old persona, even in my closest relationships. Something as common as being cut off in traffic or seeing someone looking a little too long at me can trigger old feelings of judgment and rejection. That sounds like a difficult way to live, perhaps. It’s not. I am grateful to be a therapist, since it requires me many times a day to be present with the person I am sitting with and consciously let go of any agenda to appear in a certain way. It can be a struggle, but I don’t think of struggle as a negative experience to be finally overcome; rather, it is where I start from and it is how I deepen my practice. And flourish.

1 thought on “The Archer, Part 2”

  1. Pingback: The Archer, Part 1 – michaelmckimmy.com

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *