The Archer, Part 1

In praise of difficult times

If you are familiar with the name Paulo Coelho, I am sure it is because you have read or heard about The Alchemist. The story of the journey of a young man seeking his fortune and travelling with an alchemist has taught life lessons to countless readers. Unknown until celebrities mentioned it to Oprah and she added it to her book club, it became well known around the world. The book did not begin the cliché “the journey is the destination,” but it certainly became one of its most popular examples. Interestingly, a subsequent publication, The Archer (2020), has not been met with the same acclaim, but I find it gives insights into spirituality and living a meaningful life with greater depth and nuance than its famous predecessor. The journey may be the destination, but it’s not an expected, welcomed or all-benevolent trip we’re on. In this and the next post I want to look at just a few of the teachings in this short tale.

Many critics accuse it of having a thin plot, but to be fair, the opening section is labelled a “Prologue.” It simply gives a context for the teachings that follow. Let’s begin with that story.

A summary

Tetsuya is an old man who works as a carpenter but until he retired was the most skilled archer of his day. He is hunted down by an archer who feels he has trained to perfection and wants the chance to have Tetsuya see his talent and superiority.

Tetsuya agrees. The challenger makes an impressive shot. Tetsuya takes him into the mountains along with a young helper. Walking to the middle of a dilapidated bridge over a rushing river, he calmly assumes the right posture, the right method of pulling back the bow, and his arrow finds a peach. The challenger attempts the same but is so frightened he misses the entire tree. The boy is so impressed with the ability of his teacher he wants to be trained in the “way of the bow.”

Tetsuya does not criticize the challenger and acknowledges his skill, but tells his student that, apart from practice and dedication, one has never mastered a skill until one can perform in difficult and threatening circumstances.

The boy listens as Tetsuya expounds on the lessons about the arrow, the bow, the stance, aim and attitude toward competitors as principles applicable to any way of life.

The main theme of maintaining mastery in adversity as true mastery is a profound but counterintuitive truth. Profound because it can alter my reactions, at least my second reaction, in difficult, even threatening situations. Counterintuitive because my first reaction when faced with difficulty is to pull back, avoid, wish it would go away. Instead, the insight here is to accept it and respond with all my experience and values.

I see this insight at work in therapy and our lives in general. In this post I’ll stick with therapy. When I work with a client with anxiety, for example, the client enters initially with the desire to eliminate anxiety altogether. The bad news comes usually in the first session: the goal is management, not elimination. The process is to learn strategies to regain control of their thoughts and feelings. For instance, I often begin by suggesting the person experiment with meditation of some sort. Sometimes I find a new client will already have some form of meditation or yoga practice as part of their routine. For example, some time ago a new client was struggling with free-floating anxiety, usually beginning when they walked into their workplace and lasting until midday. When I suggested meditation as a strategy for dealing with anxiety, they said they had been practicing both meditation and yoga for several years. While they never felt anxiety during their practice, even simple deep breathing during intense anxiety did nothing.

No amount of practicing a skill, archery or meditation, is a guarantee of mastery. It sounds overly simple or a cliché, but we need to face and even embrace adversity to truly master a skill. While relaxation and concentration techniques were effective “on the cushion and on the mat,” they viewed anxiety as an interruption of the experience of being centered, particularly outside those special, protected spaces. We talked about a change in perspective where anxiety would be seen as the cutting edge of their spiritual growth in whatever context: the cushion, the mat, the office.

I am aware that similar points are made by a variety of thinkers and in many traditions. Eckhart Tolle talks of problems being challenges or opportunities. Rumi said, “The wound is the place where the Light enters you.” Leonard Cohen, in his song “Anthem,” found the light coming in through the cracks in everything. Daoism tells us to drop judgments like good/bad to experience the flow in this moment. I think what Coelho accents in The Archer is that the process of gaining a skill requires the inconvenient surprises of all kinds in our lives.

In focusing on the skill we are trying to develop and welcoming the disruption, the indifference, the surprise, we grow.

Find your rickety wooden bridge, become familiar with standing on it, and concentrate on the target, not the bridge.

But this lesson goes much deeper. For Tetsuya. For us. That’s next.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *